Top 5 Silent Comedies – Radio Nan Gàidheal

A few weeks ago BBC Radio Nan Gàidheal got in contact with me to ask if I’d like to appear on their afternoon programme, Feasgar, to talk about my top 5 of any topic that interested me.
I was chuffed to bits to be asked, so I suggested silent comedies, something that I absolutely love.
In preparation for it I wrote out a series of notes to help me structure my thoughts.
I’ve fleshed out the notes into a blog post as I thought it may be of interest to some folk out there.
I’m sure many people will have similar memories of the slot before Neighbours came into existence, so this one is for you!
Although my notes are in English I spoke in Gaelic on the programme.
I was delighted to talk with the ever brilliant Niall Iain Dòmhnallach for Feasgar on the 12th of June 2025.


I first saw silent comedies as a young child on BBC 1 in the space where Neighbours was eventually scheduled. There were all sorts of things that were shown in that spot including Hooray for Harold Lloyd, Laurel and Hardy and perhaps, if my memory serves me correctly, the animated Star Trek series.

I loved watching these silent comedies as a wee man but didn’t really think about them all that much, they were just something that was there and I enjoyed.


Years later I went to Queen Margaret in Edinburgh to study theatre I was struck by how static and boring the majority of the work I was seeing was. 
It was an era of very fixed staging by directors with little passion or imagination, sat festering in comfortable jobs. God it was a tedious time for theatre in Scotland.
The only things that really got me excited were things which were physical or dynamic in some way and had usually come from further afield.
Most of these productions had a basis in a tradition that seemed very different to what I’d be experiencing up until that point. We were very lucky at QM, our teachers were very fine and filled us with all sorts of inspiration and hope for a theatre that we weren’t seeing out there, but hoping to make.
One of the key companies that influenced me were the Right Size who were Hamish MacColl and Sean Foley, often working with their director, Jos Houben. Their work opened up comedy and play in a way that I’d never seen before. It was so much fun, yet deep and sincere in its emotional content. Their wok remains a guiding light for me to this day.
Looking at the roots of companies like The Right Size I’d decided that the place I wanted to apply to go and study at was the Ècole Jacques LeCoq in Paris. So in my 4th year I studied contemporary clowning for my dissertation focusing on contemporary clowning by looking at the work of the Right Size and the incredible clown Nola Rae. 
This research project lead me to look at the silent clowns. I already had some L&H on VHS which I loved, particularly on seeing Jimmy Finlayson from Falkirk in there. Way Out West was a favourite, not a silent but very, very good.

After graduating from QM in 2000 I moved to Paris and was lucky enough to study at LeCoq.
One of the things that surprised me about Paris at that time was the availability of cheap copies of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton DVD’s at news stands around the town.
Suddenly you could see all of these amazing movies from the past for very little money.
Back in the UK 
Fopp was a great store for getting a hold of the Keaton films in particular.

At that time I had a tiny laptop which could play DVDs. My friends and I would gather around my laptop in my similarly tiny Parisian flat to watch these old films all together. It was rather comical.


DVD was a brilliant format for these films, though, as you could go through them and take the routines apart and try and figure out how they worked which we could then try out at LeCoq. It was like another teacher. Learning from the very best!

The thing that really struck me was how stories were so often built from gags and how the greats like Keaton and Chaplin organically grew amazing gags out of situations which then built to tell a story.

A brilliant example being Charlie picking up a flag in the street in Modern Times and waving it about to highlight that someone had lost it, then, by chance a workers rights protest appears behind him and suddenly he’s at the front waving his flag an leading them by complete accident.
Just the best in viaual storytelling.

Chaplin and Stan Laurel share their roots in the music hall of C19th and learned a lot of their trade with Fred Karno, a legendary impresario and total rogue.

Laurel was Chaplin’s understudy on stage in tours of America.
There’s brilliant tales of them cooking lamb chops over gas lights in their lodgings and trying to hide the fact from the landlady.

The more I watched the work of the different filmmakers I realised they all had different strengths.
I love Keaton so much. His shorter films are just amazing, but his longer films don’t hold together so well for me. The stories always feel stretched and like three short films pulled together into one.

Chaplin, though, I much prefer his longer puttings to his shorter works.
He really grows in his storytelling throughout his films.
I find his shorts impressive but often quite annoying.
It’s often like they’re exploring one idea and they never get beyond that.

Chaplin could also often be quite cruel in his short films, whereas in his longer ones he mostly sticks to variations on the Little Fellow character, who is a point of great naivety and curiosity.

Keaton was pretty much always the most noble of idiots.
It was often the principals of an idiot that drove him, that and a flawless moral code that often only he understood.
This point of naivety is the perfect place from which to build clown stories.


L & H being a double act was another thing entirely. The balance between the two characters spun open such a wide variety of stories. The idiot who thinks he’s brighter than the idiot next to him is such a brilliant way create dynamic stories.

Some years after my studies I was working in Malta and I got a chance to see the Kid by Chaplin on the big screen, outdoors with live music. It was wonderful!
It made me realise though that film changes when you see it on a big screen. These falls have real gravity to them, the drama and emotion is amplified by scale. It’s intimate, yet epic. What a fascinating art form it is!

In terms of the top 5…
Starting at the bottom:

5 – The Plank by Eric Sykes featuring Tommy Cooper. 
I’m sure I saw this when I was wee with my Grandfather. 
The last time I saw it was with my wife, son and my Mum, so it’s closely tied into family for me.
It’s the tale of a plank making its way from the lumber yard to the building site and all the chaos that goes with it. 
There’s a sequence in there where a kitten possibly gets sealed in under a floor and the builders have to try and find out where it has got to. It just builds and builds up. It’s so utterly stupid, I love it.

The strength of the Plank is in the reactions. No one over plays anything, it’s all really nicely played. They take their time in reacting to things and allow us to laugh and to build our laughter, too. 
Sykes was a massive fan of silent comedy and this is such a brilliant tribute to it. 


4 – Liberty by L&H
What a film. Escaped convicts get the wrong trousers and end up in trouble.
I only saw this film recently when I was working with Neil Brand, the composer, playwright and silent film accompanist extraordinaire.
To see it with live music is really the thing. And on the big screen, too!
The skyscraper stuff with a crab in the trousers is just amazing. You feel the terror of the height!

Stan wanted to show Oli that it was safe up there, so he dove off the side of the structure into the safety net below – but it broke and he fell 20 feet!
It was all fixed and made secure afterwards though. Jings!


3 – Sherlock Jnr – Keaton
I was drawn between this and One Week, but I think Sherlock Jr has edged it.
This film is so full of invention. It’s about the good guy getting the girl although the bad guy has the, wrong gained, upper hand.
The sequences are superb. I love the following sequence. It’s so tight. I use it for teaching film all the time.
He even breaks his neck on the fall from the water tank, hitting the rail with his neck on the way down, but he didn’t know until years later when he went for a scan. If you watch it he even gets up an runs away! An amazing man.
The dream sequence where he enters the film is so good, pure imagination. THere’s so much going on there. He only did one take with the lions though!


2 – Modern Times – Chaplin
Chaplin was accused of Communist sympathies by the House Un-American Activities Committee. This film would have been used as evidence.
It’s about the struggle of the working man, rising up from having nothing and trying to fit into the modern workplace.

The sequence in the factory where he gets driven insane by performing the same activity again and again is so true to this day. Yet it’s hilarious. He’s so successful in his humour that sometimes we loose this.

I love the peril of the skating sequence, it’s quite brilliant. So much fun. Confidence then flipped into fear. Amazing use of space and music.

This is also the film where he finally speaks. Talkies had come in some time before, but this was his first time speaking / singing on film. What a beautiful voice he has, too.

1 – City Lights
Again a film about the struggle of the working man, a beautiful soul at the bottom of the pecking order. 
There are so many brilliant sequences in this film. The changing room, the boxing rink. The drunk millionaire who wants to kill himself, but the Little Fellow saves him, and then when he sobers up he can’t remember his saviour. Proper Brecht! 
The main thrust of the story is about how the Little Fellow is mistaken for a rich business man by a blind flower seller. 
He falls for her and works and works to get her an operation to save her eyesight, which works. 
But by the time she’s ready to see him with her own eyes, he’s been arrested on his way to her and put into jail for something he didn’t do.
When he’s released months later he goes to see her at her usual place, but she’s not there. He’s heartbroken. He stops to pick up a flower from the ground and sees the flower seller in the window looking at him, laughing at his funny ways. 
She offers him a new flower and a coin, and it’s only on being close to him and pressing her hand along his hand and arm she realises who he is. 
The last lines on the inter titles are “You?” “You can see now?” And “Yes, I can see now.” He touches her heart and that’s it – buckets of tears from me. 
It’s so simple and beautiful. Just wonderful. 
It’s a film I love to watch with my family. Even just thinking about it makes me well up! 



Share your thoughts